The v19 edition models the programme on IG spread bets. This addendum takes the same three books, at 15%, 25% and
40% volatility targets with the 75% margin cap, and prices them at Interactive Brokers (IB) futures costs instead: IB's
commission and an estimated one-tick spread on every trade, a calendar spread at each roll, no funding charge, and interest
on cash. The positions do not change; only the costs do.
Addendum to the v19 editionSame positions, costs re-basedIB costs estimated, not measuredData to 13 Nov 2026
Read this first: this is not a tradable IB account
A small account cannot hold whole futures contracts in most of these markets. Even taking the smallest contract IB offers in
each market (a micro or mini where one exists), one contract is larger than the book's average position in 20 of the 23
markets at the 15% target, 19 at 25% and 18 at 40%. Section 06 estimates the capital at which the book can be held closely in whole contracts: about £320,000 at the 15% target, £200,000 at 25% and £130,000 at 40%.
So this page compares the cost of the same book, held in the same fractional sizes as the backtest, at two brokers. It is not a
backtest of an IB account of that size, which would have to round every position to whole contracts and would hold a different book.
The IB costs are estimates from a cost model, not measured fills.
01 · At a glance
The same positions, about a sixth of the cost
1.3%Costs a year at IB, 15% target (IG 8.0%)
2.1%Costs a year at IB, 25% target (IG 13.1%)
3.1%Costs a year at IB, 40% target (IG 19.4%)
1.09Sharpe over SONIA at IB, 15% target (IG 0.60)
1.12Sharpe over SONIA at IB, 25% target (IG 0.66)
1.12Sharpe over SONIA at IB, 40% target (IG 0.69)
Return a year at each target
15% target25% target40% targetIG (pale)IB (solid)
Backtest 26 Dec 2018 to 13 Nov 2026, the held book with the 75% margin cap, GBP, compounding. IB: estimated futures costs, interest on cash at IB's published GBP rate. IG: the v19 edition's costs and basis, no interest on cash.
Costs a year
Sharpe over SONIA
Return a year
Worst drawdown
Book
IG
IB
IG
IB
IG
IB
IG
IB
15% target
8.0%
1.3%
0.60
1.09
11.6%
21.0%
−19.1%
−14.9%
25% target
13.1%
2.1%
0.66
1.12
18.3%
33.8%
−30.7%
−24.2%
40% target
19.4%
3.1%
0.69
1.12
24.8%
48.8%
−42.0%
−32.7%
At IB the same book costs about 1.3% a year at 15% instead of 8.0%, 2.1% instead of 13.1% at 25% and 3.1% instead of 19.4% at 40%. Most of the saving is IG's funding charge on rolling spread bets, which a future does not pay: 4.5% of the 6.7% saved at 15%. The rest is cheaper trading and rolling, mostly in grains and softs, slightly offset in currencies, where IG's spread bets trade at about one futures tick or less and IB adds commission.
With costs that much lower, the Sharpe ratio over SONIA rises from 0.60 to 1.09 at 15%, and the worst drawdown is shallower at every target, because the same positions lose less to cost on the way down. IB also pays interest on cash, which IG does not on spread-bet accounts; without that interest the IB Sharpe over SONIA would be 1.01 at 15%. None of this changes the point at the top: a small account could not hold this book at IB. Section 06 gives the capital it would take.
02 · Costs
Trading, roll and funding, IG against IB
Costs a year at each target
15% target25% target40% targetIG trading and rollIG fundingIB trading and roll
% of NAV a year (mean daily cost × 252), on the book held. IG: the v19 edition's cost model (each market's spread, funding on rolling bets, roll on dated bets). IB: estimated futures costs.
15% target
25% target
40% target
Component
IG
IB
IG
IB
IG
IB
Trading (spread and commission)
3.12%
1.13%
5.09%
1.84%
7.38%
2.64%
Roll
0.35%
0.18%
0.57%
0.30%
0.84%
0.45%
Funding
4.52%
0.00%
7.45%
0.00%
11.14%
0.00%
Total
7.99%
1.31%
13.11%
2.14%
19.36%
3.09%
Where the difference comes from, at the 15% target
% of NAV a year by asset class, 15% target. The 25% and 40% books hold larger positions in the same markets, so their costs scale up with them.
IG
IB
Asset class
Trading
Funding and roll
Total
Trading
Roll
Total
Currencies
0.09%
2.06%
2.15%
0.14%
0.03%
0.18%
Rates
0.62%
0.19%
0.80%
0.24%
0.04%
0.28%
Equity indices
0.09%
0.34%
0.43%
0.07%
0.01%
0.08%
Metals
0.39%
0.35%
0.73%
0.09%
0.01%
0.11%
Grains and softs
1.93%
1.94%
3.87%
0.58%
0.09%
0.67%
All markets
3.12%
4.87%
7.99%
1.13%
0.18%
1.31%
Currencies trade dearer at IB, but cost less in total. IG quotes three of the four currency spread bets inside one futures tick, and IB adds commission on top, so trading costs 0.14% a year at IB against 0.09% at IG. IG's funding on those rolling bets, 2.06% a year, outweighs it.
Grains and softs are where trading costs fall most, from 1.93% to 0.58% a year: IG's spreads on these markets are two to fourteen futures ticks wide.
Every market rolls at IB. At IG only the dated bets roll; rolling bets pay funding instead. At IB all 23 markets are dated futures, rolled four or five times a year as a calendar spread, and the roll still costs less than IG's: 0.18% a year against 0.35% at 15%.
03 · Returns and risk
Sharpe, return and drawdown, IG against IB
Growth of £1, IG against IB
15% target25% target40% targetIGIB
Log scale, weekly points. IB includes interest on cash at IB's published GBP rate, as in the table; IG has none.
Sharpe over SONIA: mean ÷ standard deviation of the daily return less the Bank of England SONIA rate, × √252. Return a year: compound, calendar time. IB: interest on cash at IB's published GBP rate; the range runs from no interest to full SONIA on the whole balance. IG pays no interest on cash in spread-bet accounts.
Sharpe over SONIA
Return a year
Volatility
Worst drawdown
Book
IG
IB
IB range
IG
IB
IB range
IG
IB
IG
IB
15% target
0.60
1.09
1.01 to 1.16
11.6%
21.0%
19.3% to 22.3%
16.5%
16.5%
−19.1%
−14.9%
25% target
0.66
1.12
1.07 to 1.16
18.3%
33.8%
31.9% to 35.2%
27.2%
27.2%
−30.7%
−24.2%
40% target
0.69
1.12
1.08 to 1.14
24.8%
48.8%
46.7% to 50.4%
41.1%
41.1%
−42.0%
−32.7%
Interest on cash. IB pays interest on cash balances; IG pays none on spread-bet accounts. IB's published rate for sterling, as recorded in September 2026, is the benchmark less 0.50% on the balance above £8,000 and nothing below it. On a small balance that is well below SONIA. The whole balance is assumed to earn it, since futures margin is posted from the account's own cash. Any condition IB attaches for smaller accounts is not in that record; the range in the table runs from no interest at all to full SONIA on the whole balance.
Same risk, less drag. Volatility is the same at both brokers, because the positions are the same. The worst drawdown at 15% runs from 10 Jul 2024 to 23 May 2025 at IG (−19.1%) and from 10 Jul 2024 to 8 Oct 2024 at IB (−14.9%). It is the same episode; at IB it bottoms out months earlier, because costs no longer pull the account down while the positions mark time.
* Partial years: 26–31 Dec 2018 and 1 Jan – 13 Nov 2026.
Calendar-year returns, daily returns compounded within the year. IB includes interest on cash at IB's published GBP rate; IG has none.
15% target
25% target
40% target
Year
IG
IB
IG
IB
IG
IB
2018 (from 26 Dec)
+0.6%
+0.7%
+0.6%
+0.7%
+0.6%
+0.7%
2019
+8.8%
+19.1%
+12.1%
+29.4%
+4.9%
+26.3%
2020
+9.5%
+17.3%
+16.2%
+29.5%
+27.5%
+49.5%
2021
+9.4%
+16.8%
+14.4%
+27.5%
+18.4%
+39.8%
2022
+34.1%
+41.0%
+60.8%
+74.2%
+106.7%
+134.0%
2023
−3.6%
+6.0%
−7.5%
+6.5%
−15.4%
+3.7%
2024
+38.5%
+51.6%
+69.5%
+93.0%
+124.0%
+168.9%
2025
+4.5%
+15.4%
+6.4%
+23.4%
+6.6%
+31.1%
2026 (to 13 Nov)
−3.1%
+4.4%
−6.6%
+4.5%
−14.0%
+0.9%
The IB book is ahead in every year, by about 9% a year on average at 15%, 16% at 25% and 26% at 40% over the full years 2019 to 2025. At 15%, IG's losing years (2023, 2026) are small gains at IB. Cost is a steady drag that grows with the target, so the gap is similar from year to year; the strong years (2022 and 2024) and the weak ones (2023 and 2026) are the same at both brokers.
06 · Minimum capital
How much capital the book needs in whole contracts
At IB every position is a whole number of contracts. Here each book is held in the smallest contract IB lists in each market (a micro or mini where one exists) at a fixed capital: each day's position is rounded to the nearest whole contract, and the result is compared with the fractional book used in the rest of this addendum. The test was fixed before any figure was read. The minimum viable capital is the smallest capital at which the whole-contract book's tracking error is no more than a quarter of the book's own volatility, a daily correlation of about 0.97, and stays within that at every larger capital.
£320,000Minimum viable capital, 15% target
£200,000Minimum viable capital, 25% target
£130,000Minimum viable capital, 40% target
Backtest 26 Dec 2018 to 13 Nov 2026, the same three books as above, each held at a constant capital (positions sized on it every day). Contract values from each day's unadjusted futures close and GBP/USD. Capitals were tested at 20 steps a decade; each figure is the first step that passes, to two significant figures.
15% target
25% target
40% target
Minimum viable: tracking error up to a quarter of the book's volatility
£320,000
£200,000
£130,000
Closer: up to a tenth
£890,000
£560,000
£360,000
Looser: up to a half
£71,000
£45,000
£28,000
Rule of thumb: at least four contracts in every market's average position
£6.3m
£3.8m
£2.5m
How closely whole contracts track the book, by capital
Tracking error as a share of the book's volatility, with the daily correlation in brackets.
15% target
25% target
40% target
£100,000
42% (0.910)
33% (0.944)
28% (0.960)
£250,000
27% (0.962)
19% (0.981)
13% (0.992)
£500,000
17% (0.986)
10% (0.995)
6% (0.998)
£1 million
8% (0.997)
5% (0.999)
3% (0.999)
£2.5 million
4% (0.999)
2% (1.000)
1% (1.000)
The higher targets hold larger positions, so the same contracts fit at less capital: the 40% book needs about two-fifths of the 15% book's. Below the minimum, single contracts in the larger markets swing the book. Between £100,000 and £500,000, rounding still moves the backtest's Sharpe ratio over SONIA by as much as 0.16, by chance; by £1 million it is within 0.01 of the fractional book's at every target. Whole contracts also trade a little more, adding about 0.05 to 0.06 points a year to IB costs at £500,000.
A common rule of thumb for futures traders, at least four contracts in every market's average position, asks far more. One market's smallest contract is large and has no micro version, and that one market sets the whole figure.
Not modelled here: IB's own margin requirement (the IG cap's trims are kept, as in the rest of this addendum), the cost of converting currency, the higher commission per pound on micro and mini contracts, and a no-trade band, which would cut trading but not the tracking error much.
08 · How it is costed
How the IB figures are built, and what they leave out
Positions. The three v19 books exactly as the v19 edition holds them: the book set at each close after the 75% margin cap, earning the next day's market moves. The cap's trims are IG's margin rule and are kept, because the positions are the same. Gross returns are unchanged; only costs are re-based.
Trading cost at IB (estimated). Each trade pays half a tick of spread plus IB's commission per contract on each side (USD 1.35 a standard contract on its tiered schedule with typical exchange fees, as the programme records it; USD 2.00 for the ICE softs). Both are turned into a cost per pound traded at each year's median price, so a market whose price has risen costs less per pound than it did. This is a model of the futures tick and IB's published schedule, not measured fills; IB's real costs can be higher in fast markets and for larger orders.
No funding. A future carries no overnight funding charge: the cost of carry is already in its price, and the backtest's prices are futures-based. IG's charge on rolling spread bets does not apply.
Roll. Every market is a dated future, rolled on the exchange's contract cycle (four or five times a year, depending on the market) a few days before expiry or first notice. Each roll is one calendar-spread order: half a tick plus a commission on each of its two legs.
Cash. IB's published interest on sterling cash (the benchmark less 0.50% above £8,000, nothing below), on the account's balance, with the Bank of England SONIA rate as the benchmark. Sharpe ratios are over SONIA. IG: no interest, as the v19 edition.
Not modelled
Whole contracts. The book is held in fractional sizes, as in the backtest. At IB every position would round to whole contracts, which for a small account means holding none or one in most markets. The estimate also uses standard contracts throughout; micro and mini contracts cost more commission per pound traded. Section 06 measures how closely whole contracts track the book at each capital.
Currency conversion. The contracts are in US dollars and the account in sterling. The cost of converting, and the currency exposure on margin and on profits and losses held in dollars, are not included.
IB's margin rule. IB sets its own futures margins. They are not applied; the IG cap's trims are kept instead.
Fees outside trading. Market-data subscriptions, account minimums and any monthly fees.
How much the IB estimate matters
At today's prices throughout. Charging every year at the November 2026 price level, instead of each year's own, puts IB's trading and roll at 1.17% a year at 15% (against 1.31%) and the Sharpe over SONIA at 1.10.
Rolling as two separate trades instead of one spread order costs 0.29% a year at 15% (against 0.18%); Sharpe over SONIA 1.09.
Twice the estimated IB trading and roll cost gives a Sharpe over SONIA of 1.01 at 15%, 1.04 at 25% and 1.04 at 40%, still above IG's at the model's own costs.
09 · Important information
Important information
This addendum describes a personal research project. It is not an offer, solicitation or invitation to invest, and it is not investment advice. No fund, managed account or other investment product based on this research exists, and none is offered.
Performance shown is hypothetical. It comes from a computer simulation applied with hindsight and has inherent limits: no actual trading took place, and results may not reflect liquidity, market conditions or decisions made under real risk. The IB figures re-price the same simulated positions with estimated futures costs; they are not the results of an IB account, and a small account could not hold these positions in whole contracts. Results are before fees and tax. Past performance, simulated or actual, is not a reliable indicator of future results. Trading futures and leveraged derivatives involves substantial risk of loss.
Interactive Brokers and IG are named only to describe their published charges; neither has reviewed this material. Interest rates: Bank of England SONIA, to 11 Nov 2026, carried forward to 13 Nov 2026. Data as of 13 Nov 2026.